Background
In May 2015, the AcSB approved a research project to understand current Canadian and international practices for recognizing revenue from contributions. In January 2016, the Board created its Not-for-Profit Advisory Committee (the Committee) to assist with maintaining and improving accounting standards for NFPOs.
In May 2020, the AcSB issued the Consultation Paper, “Contributions – Revenue Recognition and Related Matters,” to obtain input from interested and affected parties on the accounting for contributions and related matters. In March 2022, in response to feedback on the Consultation Paper, the Board decided to proceed with a standard-setting project to amend the guidance in Part III of the CPA Canada Handbook – Accounting Standards for Not-for-Profit Organizations for contributions and related matters.
In March 2023, the AcSB issued the Exposure Draft, “Contributions – Revenue Recognition and Related Matters” (the “2023 Exposure Draft”), which proposed a single approach for recognizing revenue from restricted contributions. Under this method, restricted contributions would be recognized as the related restrictions are met. Feedback on the proposals was mixed, with a small majority of respondents supporting the proposed recognition model. However, those who disagreed with the proposals provided compelling arguments and additional information supporting the need to maintain two contribution revenue recognition methods.
The AcSB considered options to address this feedback and sought input by conducting additional targeted outreach sessions. Most outreach participants agreed that additional presentation or disclosure requirements alone would not address concerns raised on the 2023 Exposure Draft. Financial statement users continued to support a single recognition approach for restricted contributions but reaffirmed that they can navigate the two current methods and do not have concerns about comparability.
After significant consideration of both the feedback on the 2023 Exposure Draft and the additional outreach conducted, the AcSB concluded that a single recognition model may not meet the diverse needs of the not-for-profit sector and that the benefits to financial statement users may not exceed the cost to preparers. The Board decided to develop a new Exposure Draft that would continue to allow an accounting policy choice for recognizing contributions, with the objective of improving the quality and understandability of the financial statements through improved consistency in the application of the Standard.